• Podcast
  • ARL
    • Indigenous All Stars v NRL All Stars
    • Rugby League State Of Origin
  • NRL
    • 2025 NRL Draw
    • 2024 NRL Draw
    • 2023 NRL Draw
    • 2022 NRL Draw
    • 2021 NRL Draw
    • 2022 NRL Podcast
    • 2020 NRL Draw
    • 2015 NRL Draw
    • 2014 NRL Draw
  • ESL
    • International Origin
    • Challenge Cup
  • World
    • World Club Challenge
    • World Cup
    • Rugby League 9’s
    • NRL Auckland Nines Draw
  • Sports
    • AFL
    • Cricket
    • Rugby Union
    • Soccer
  • Guest Writers
  • League Freak
    • NRL Tipping Experts
    • Web Site News
    • Sponsorship
    • Uncategorized

The Glorious League Freak – Covering Rugby League World Wide – LeagueFreak.com

  • Home
  • Podcast
  • NRL Rumours
  • RL World 9’s
  • Features
    • Player Profiles And News
  • History
    • History Books
    • The Super League War
      • The Super League War – The Clubs
      • The Super League War – The Freak
      • The Super League War – The Extras
  • Quotes
  • Look-Alikes
  • Teams
  • Rankings
  • Media
  • About
    • Bio
    • League Freaks Commentary Career
    • Contact
    • League Freak On Twitter
    • I Am Not A Journalist
    • Contribute To LeagueFreak.com
    • League Freak Mentions In The Media
    • Advertise On This Website
    • Rugby League RSS Feed
  • follow
    • Facebook
    • Twitter
    • Google+
    • RSS Feed
    • Linked
    • Youtube

Queensland Is Whinging About State Of Origin Eligibility Rules…AGAIN!

Jan 17, 2014 League Freak Rugby League State Of Origin 2


Would you be shocked if I told you that Queensland was whinging once again about State Of Origin eligibility rules?

This time the issue surrounds South Sydney youngster Luke Keary. Keary was born in Queensland but moved to New South Wales at a young enough age that he no longer qualifies to play for Queensland. Keary played all of his junior representative football in New South Wales but that isn’t good enough for Queensland!

According to Queensland is it wrong that Keary was born north of the border but can not play for the Maroons.

That in my opinion is fair enough. I’d suggest that if that is how Queensland wants things to be we should change the eligibility rules so that you only play for the state you were born in.

Here is where it gets weird….

Queensland would also hate that idea. See they believe that if you were born outside of Queensland you should also be allowed to represent Queensland. They want to be able to have their cake and eat it too.

When the Australian Rugby League Commission was established one of the first things they did was clear up State Of Origin eligibility rules. The previous rules that has been in place for many years no longer worked. They allowed so many loopholes that State Of Origin was slowly becoming a farce. An international all star game that saw BOTH states actively recruiting players that were not from Queensland or New South Wales.

While the new State Of Origin rules are far from ideal, they at least allow a clear set of guidelines for players and states to use to know who can play where and why. Its all black and white and allows no room for interpretation of thye rules…which was the downfall of the previous set of eligiligty rules.

Oh course, the current rules allow BOTH states to continue to pick players that were not even born in Australia. Something that I find not only ridiculous, but that undermines international Rugby League terribly.

I tend to think that the current rules are a stepping stone towards much tighter eligibility rules that will eventually be very simple. You play for the state you were born in. If you want to play for a state but you weren’t born there…tough luck!

Keary is a very good young player. When he made his first grade debut you could see he had all the potential in the world. I can understand why ANY coach would want him in their side. He is a player of the future.

I can understand that being born in Queensland might make him want to play for Queensland, but under the current rules, he can’t. That should be the end of it. Mal Meninga shouldn’t be taking to the press every time he can’t recruit a player and whinging about it.

The thing is, State Of Origin is supposed to be about NSW taking on QLD. We are told over and over against that state pride is on the line. That players play Origin football with passion.

State Of Origin should not be played between two teams that recruited players. It should not be played by players who decided to play for one state or the other.

You’re either from New South Wales, Queensland, or you not involved in the series at all. That is how it should be!

  • Tweet
  • Share 0
  • Reddit
  • Pocket
  • LinkedIn 0
  • Email

Related


  • Eligibility Rules, Luke Keary, Mal Meninga, Queensland, State Of Origin
  • tweet
Panthers Fullback James Roberts Breaks Ankle At Training Daniel Nichols - The Charity Shield Is Off To The ‘Gong’

League Freak

A well known Rugby League writer, League Freak has established a reputation among supporters of the game for his fearless commentary and unmatched insight. With a reach that spans both sides of the globe, League Freak has produced an independent network that allows him to distribute content to his many thousands of followers. He is the owner and main author of LeagueFreak.com

Related articles
  • Latrell Mitchell Ruled Out Of State Of Origin One
    Latrell Mitchell Ruled Out Of State Of...

    May 29, 2023 0

  • NRL Podcast: Fergo and The Freak – Ep418 – Queensland Wins An Epic State Of Origin Series!!!
    NRL Podcast: Fergo and The Freak...

    Jul 13, 2022 0

  • NRL Podcast: Fergo and The Freak – Ep417 – Tim Sheens…..You Cheeky B#######! – Plus State Of Origin 3 Preview!
    NRL Podcast: Fergo and The Freak...

    Jul 13, 2022 0


2 thoughts on “Queensland Is Whinging About State Of Origin Eligibility Rules…AGAIN!”

  1. gregor 17/01/2014 at 10:03 am

    so if they get keary does that mean we can get inglis back?

    Log in to Reply ↓
    1. League Freak Post author17/01/2014 at 5:49 pm

      That seems fair to me!

      Log in to Reply ↓

You must log in to post a comment.

League Freaks Social Network

Follow League Freak on:

Become a Patron!

Ziad Warwar
Nadine
Coojee
Adam
Andy
jamescunni
Lisa
Rugby League Project
Karsten Brumme
Samuel
Sandy
Katey
Jack
Terry
Gibbo

RSS Fergo and The Freak Podcast

  • "Potential Profit In The Profit Sense Of The Word"
  • Bonus Episode: IMG Changing The English Game, A Coaching Change At The Dragons
  • France No Longer Hosting The 2025 Rugby League World Cup
  • What Does WAP Stand For?
  • Dylbags With Julie
  • A Plethora Of Stupid Ideas
  • Casting An Eye Over All 17 NRL Teams Right Now
  • Venting About The Wests Tigers
  • The Prodigal Son Returns!
  • There's Quite A Bit To Talk About In Rugby League Today!
  • The 2023 NRL Season Preview
  • The First #AskKenty Of 2023
  • League Freak HUMILIATED As St Helens Beat Penrith To Win The World Club Challenge
  • Street Food In Castleford And The Patron Saint Of Divorce
  • We Will Learn A Lot This Season

Polls

In The On Field Quality Of Super League Games Getting Better Or Worse?

View Results

Loading ... Loading ...
  • Polls Archive

Latest Rugby League Articles

  • When Will State Of Origin Stars Get To Play International Football Again?
    When Will State Of Origin Stars Get To Play International...

    May 30, 2023 0

  • Latrell Mitchell Ruled Out Of State Of Origin One
    Latrell Mitchell Ruled Out Of State Of Origin One

    May 29, 2023 0

  • NRL Podcast: “Potential Profit In The Profit Sense Of The Word”
    NRL Podcast: “Potential Profit In The Profit Sense Of...

    May 28, 2023 0

  • The 2022 World Cup Legacy Feels A Lot Like The 2000 World Cup Legacy
    The 2022 World Cup Legacy Feels A Lot Like The 2000 World...

    May 26, 2023 0

  • Who Reigns the NRL TELSTRA Premiership? Here Is the Season Standing
    Who Reigns the NRL TELSTRA Premiership? Here Is the Season...

    May 26, 2023 0

Follow League Freak on Twitter

My Tweets

Tags

Andrew Ferguson (379) ARL (62) Australia (159) Benji Marshall (90) Billy Slater (78) Broadcasting Deal (68) Cameron Smith (60) Channel 9 (74) Daniel Nichols (122) Disgrace (77) Eligibility Rules (64) England (143) Expansion (85) Fergo And The Freak (470) Greg Inglis (100) Guest Writer (338) Israel Folau (71) Jarryd Hayne (78) Johnathan Thurston (82) League Freak (541) Leeds Rhinos (59) Marketing (67) Matthew Elliott (71) Mitchell Pearce (64) New South Wales (107) New Zealand (143) NRL Finals (63) NRL Salary Cap (96) Paul Gallen (64) Phil Gould (59) Player Movement (132) Podcast (494) Queensland (84) Referees (78) RFL (144) Rugby League History (78) Rugby Union (209) Sam Burgess (63) Sonny Bill Williams (91) State Of Origin (182) St Helens (69) Todd Carney (62) Wayne Bennett (83) Wigan (59) World Cup (184)
As featured on NewsNow: NRL newsNRL News 24/7

Meta

  • Log in
  • Entries feed
  • Comments feed
  • WordPress.org

Blogroll

  • The Glorious League Freak.
  • League Freak on Twitter
  • League Freak on Facebook
  • Rugby League Podcasting Network
  • NRL Breaking News
  • NRL Rumours
  • RLWorld9s.com

Facebook Pages

  • NRL Gossip
  • NRL Infinite

Features

  • King Of Rugby League
  • Rugby League Look-Alikes
  • Biggest Winning Margins In Rugby League History
  • Biggest Crowds In Rugby League History
  • Rugby League Quotes
  • Rugby League Dictionary
  • The Super League War
  • The New Zealand Haka
  • Funny Rugby League Teams
  • Rugby League Rankins Lists
  • NRL Rumours
  • IHateRugbyUnion.com
  • NRL History
  • NRL History Books
  • Record Books
  • Player Profiles

NBA Links

  • NBA Rookie Of The Year
  • NBA MVP Winner List
  • NBA Finals MVPs

Other Links

  • Submit Your Australian Blog
  • Best Junk Hauling Virginia
  • Gutter Cleaning Service Virginia
  • Best Lawn Mowing Service Virginia
  • 2020 NRL Draw
  • Hot Toys Australia

Other Sports

  • Clutch Fans
  • Sportette

Players

  • Cameron Smith
  • Kalyn Ponga
  • Sonny Bill Williams
  • Jarryd Hayne
  • Andrew Johns
  • Semi Radradra
  • Sam Burgess
  • Benji Marshall
  • James Tedesco
  • Cooper Cronk
  • Johnathan Thurston
  • Anthony Mundine
  • Sam Tomkins
  • Greg Inglis
  • Jamie Peacock
  • Ntahan Cleary

Rugby League

  • Rugby League Project
  • Era Of The Biff
  • Darryl's Rugby League
  • Jamie Lyon Web
  • Rugby League Review
  • Rugby League Ratings
  • NRL CEO Fantasy League
  • QLD Panthers
  • Andrew Ferguson's Website!
  • Black Swans RLFC
  • InternationalRL
  • 2021 Rugby League World Cup
  • Rugby League Mums
  • Player Profiles
  • 2024 NRL Draw
  • Watch NRL Games Online
  • NRL Tipping Experts

Rugby League Podcast

  • Best Rugby League Podcast
  • Best NRL Podcast
  • Best Super League Podcast
  • Best Australian Podcast
  • Best Sports Podcast
  • Funniest Podcast
  • Best Comedy Podcast
  • NRL Radio
  • 2021 NRL Podcast
  • Spotify NRL Podcasts
Google+
  • National Rugby League
  • Rugby League State Of Origin
  • Brisbane Broncos
  • Canberra Raiders
  • Canterbury Bulldogs
  • Cronulla Sharks
  • Gold Coast Titans
  • Manly Sea Eagles
  • Melbourne Storm
  • The 2029 Rugby League World Cup
  • New Zealand Warriors
  • Newcastle Knights
  • North Queensland Cowboys
  • Parramatta Eels
  • Penrith Panthers
  • Redcliffe Dolphins
  • South Sydney Rabbitohs
  • St George/Illawarra Dragons
  • Sydney Roosters
  • Wests Tigers
  • The King Of Rugby League Awards
  • Rugby League Player Profiles And News
  • Fantasy Rugby League Teams
  • Rugby League World Rankings
  • Rugby League Look-Alikes
  • International Rugby League News
  • National Rugby League
  • European Super League News
  • Featured Guest Writers
  • Other Sports
  • The 2021 NRL Draw
  • The 2022 NRL Draw – Every NRL Game Listed For You!!!
  • The 2023 NRL Draw – Every NRL Game Is Here!!!
  • 2024 NRL Draw
  • NRL Player Profiles
  • NRL Instagram
  • The 2025 NRL Draw – Every Game, Every Venue, Every Club!
  • NRL Tipping Experts
  • Advertise On LeagueFreak.com
  • About LeagueFreak.com
  • Contact Us
  • RSS Feed
  • NothingButLeague.com
  • Rugby League Podcasting Network
  • NRL Breaking News
  • NRL Rumours – Latest NRL Rumours
  • NRL Podcast
  • Super League Podcast
  • Rugby League Podcast
  • Here Is The Cure For COVID 19
  • 2022 NRL Grand Final Tickets
  • Click Here To Buy State Of Origin Tickets
  • Buy NRL Tickets – Where To Buy Tickets To Rugby League Games
  • Watch NRL Games Online In 2022 – Where To Watch NRL Games Online And Streaming
Copyright LeagueFreak.com 2022 / All rights reserved
  • Advertise On LeagueFreak.com
  • About LeagueFreak.com
  • Contact Us
  • RSS Feed
  • NothingButLeague.com
  • Rugby League Podcasting Network
  • NRL Breaking News
  • NRL Rumours – Latest NRL Rumours
  • NRL Podcast
  • Super League Podcast
  • Rugby League Podcast
  • Here Is The Cure For COVID 19
  • 2022 NRL Grand Final Tickets
  • Click Here To Buy State Of Origin Tickets
  • Buy NRL Tickets – Where To Buy Tickets To Rugby League Games
  • Watch NRL Games Online In 2022 – Where To Watch NRL Games Online And Streaming